Benchmark Library — The Intractable Decathlon
Quantum OptimizationBenchmarking Library
A curated suite of ten challenging optimization problem classes, designed to enable fair,
reproducible, and meaningful benchmarks for quantum and classical optimization methods alike.
533
Optimally Solved (any)
(1) The Hartree Centre STFC (United Kingdom)
131 instances
Aqarios GmbH
5 instances
CityUHK (City University of Hong Kong)
198 instances
Forschungszentrum Jülich
254 instances
hiq-lab
7 instances
Independent Researcher
110 instances
Kipu Quantum
57 instances
Math.Tec
8 instances
Q-Bridge (South Korea)
8 instances
Qoro Quantum Ltd.
7 instances
SRIBD (Shenzhen Research Institute of Big Data)
198 instances
University of Bayreuth
115 instances
(1) The Hartree Centre STFC (United Kingdom)
131 instances
Aqarios GmbH
5 instances
CityUHK (City University of Hong Kong)
198 instances
Forschungszentrum Jülich
254 instances
hiq-lab
7 instances
Independent Researcher
110 instances
Kipu Quantum
57 instances
Math.Tec
8 instances
Q-Bridge (South Korea)
8 instances
Qoro Quantum Ltd.
7 instances
SRIBD (Shenzhen Research Institute of Big Data)
198 instances
University of Bayreuth
115 instances
(2) E.ON Digital Technology GmbH (Germany)
131 instances
AQT
8 instances
CUHKSZ (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen)
198 instances
Global Data Quantum
3 instances
IBM
1030 instances
JIJ
26 instances
Kipu Quantum and UPV/EHU
1 instance
Parity Quantum Computing GmbH
16 instances
Q-CTRL
2 instances
Qunova Computing, Inc.
5 instances
UCAS (University of Chinese Academy of Sciences)
198 instances
Zuse Institute Berlin
822 instances
(2) E.ON Digital Technology GmbH (Germany)
131 instances
AQT
8 instances
CUHKSZ (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen)
198 instances
Global Data Quantum
3 instances
IBM
1030 instances
JIJ
26 instances
Kipu Quantum and UPV/EHU
1 instance
Parity Quantum Computing GmbH
16 instances
Q-CTRL
2 instances
Qunova Computing, Inc.
5 instances
UCAS (University of Chinese Academy of Sciences)
198 instances
Zuse Institute Berlin
822 instances
(1) The Hartree Centre STFC (United Kingdom) — 131 instances
(2) E.ON Digital Technology GmbH (Germany) — 131 instances
Aqarios GmbH — 5 instances
AQT — 8 instances
CityUHK (City University of Hong Kong) — 198 instances
CUHKSZ (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen) — 198 instances
Forschungszentrum Jülich — 254 instances
Global Data Quantum — 3 instances
hiq-lab — 7 instances
IBM — 1030 instances
Independent Researcher — 110 instances
JIJ — 26 instances
Kipu Quantum — 57 instances
Kipu Quantum and UPV/EHU — 1 instance
Math.Tec — 8 instances
Parity Quantum Computing GmbH — 16 instances
Q-Bridge (South Korea) — 8 instances
Q-CTRL — 2 instances
Qoro Quantum Ltd. — 7 instances
Qunova Computing, Inc. — 5 instances
SRIBD (Shenzhen Research Institute of Big Data) — 198 instances
UCAS (University of Chinese Academy of Sciences) — 198 instances
University of Bayreuth — 115 instances
Zuse Institute Berlin — 822 instances
Contribute results
Submit a solution
Have a better bound, a new feasible solution, a quantum run, or a useful negative result?
QOBLIB accepts benchmark submissions by pull request using the canonical summary CSV template.
Complexity Landscape
Scatter plot of MIP benchmark instances by number of variables (log scale, horizontal) and constraint density (log scale, vertical), coloured by problem class. 554 of 925 instances plotted are solved to optimality. 10 100 1,000 10,000 1e5 1e6 1e-6 1e-5 1e-4 1e-3 0.01 0.1 1 Number of variables (log) Density (log) ms_03_050_002 · Market Split ms_03_050_005 · Market Split ms_03_050_007 · Market Split ms_03_050_009 · Market Split ms_03_100_001 · Market Split ms_03_100_012 · Market Split ms_03_100_019 · Market Split ms_03_100_022 · Market Split ms_03_200_050 · Market Split ms_03_200_068 · Market Split ms_03_200_161 · Market Split ms_03_200_177 · Market Split ms_04_050_001 · Market Split ms_04_050_003 · Market Split ms_04_050_004 · Market Split ms_04_050_005 · Market Split ms_04_100_003 · Market Split ms_04_100_009 · Market Split ms_04_100_013 · Market Split ms_04_100_015 · Market Split ms_04_200_030 · Market Split ms_04_200_150 · Market Split ms_04_200_174 · Market Split ms_04_200_176 · Market Split ms_05_050_001 · Market Split ms_05_050_002 · Market Split ms_05_050_003 · Market Split ms_05_050_004 · Market Split ms_05_100_003 · Market Split ms_05_100_006 · Market Split ms_05_100_013 · Market Split ms_05_100_015 · Market Split ms_05_200_070 · Market Split ms_05_200_095 · Market Split ms_05_200_180 · Market Split ms_05_200_199 · Market Split ms_06_050_001 · Market Split ms_06_050_002 · Market Split ms_06_050_003 · Market Split ms_06_050_004 · Market Split ms_06_100_002 · Market Split ms_06_100_003 · Market Split ms_06_100_005 · Market Split ms_06_100_010 · Market Split ms_06_200_077 · Market Split ms_06_200_104 · Market Split ms_06_200_240 · Market Split ms_06_200_289 · Market Split ms_07_050_001 · Market Split ms_07_050_002 · Market Split ms_07_050_003 · Market Split ms_07_050_004 · Market Split ms_07_100_002 · Market Split ms_07_100_003 · Market Split ms_07_100_005 · Market Split ms_07_100_006 · Market Split ms_07_200_248 · Market Split ms_07_200_370 · Market Split ms_07_200_398 · Market Split ms_07_200_500 · Market Split ms_08_050_000 · Market Split ms_08_050_001 · Market Split ms_08_050_002 · Market Split ms_08_050_003 · Market Split ms_08_100_000 · Market Split ms_08_100_001 · Market Split ms_08_100_002 · Market Split ms_08_100_003 · Market Split ms_08_200_000 · Market Split ms_08_200_001 · Market Split ms_08_200_002 · Market Split ms_08_200_003 · Market Split ms_09_050_000 · Market Split ms_09_050_001 · Market Split ms_09_050_002 · Market Split ms_09_050_003 · Market Split ms_09_100_000 · Market Split ms_09_100_001 · Market Split ms_09_100_002 · Market Split ms_09_100_003 · Market Split ms_09_200_000 · Market Split ms_09_200_001 · Market Split ms_09_200_002 · Market Split ms_09_200_003 · Market Split ms_10_050_000 · Market Split ms_10_050_001 · Market Split ms_10_050_002 · Market Split ms_10_050_003 · Market Split ms_10_100_000 · Market Split ms_10_100_001 · Market Split ms_10_100_002 · Market Split ms_10_100_003 · Market Split ms_10_200_000 · Market Split ms_10_200_001 · Market Split ms_10_200_002 · Market Split ms_10_200_003 · Market Split ms_11_050_000 · Market Split ms_11_050_001 · Market Split ms_11_050_002 · Market Split ms_11_050_003 · Market Split ms_11_100_000 · Market Split ms_11_100_001 · Market Split ms_11_100_002 · Market Split ms_11_100_003 · Market Split ms_11_200_000 · Market Split ms_11_200_001 · Market Split ms_11_200_002 · Market Split ms_11_200_003 · Market Split ms_12_050_000 · Market Split ms_12_050_001 · Market Split ms_12_050_002 · Market Split ms_12_050_003 · Market Split ms_12_100_000 · Market Split ms_12_100_001 · Market Split ms_12_100_002 · Market Split ms_12_100_003 · Market Split ms_12_200_000 · Market Split ms_12_200_001 · Market Split ms_12_200_002 · Market Split ms_12_200_003 · Market Split ms_13_050_000 · Market Split ms_13_050_001 · Market Split ms_13_050_002 · Market Split ms_13_050_003 · Market Split ms_13_100_000 · Market Split ms_13_100_001 · Market Split ms_13_100_002 · Market Split ms_13_100_003 · Market Split ms_13_200_000 · Market Split ms_13_200_001 · Market Split ms_13_200_002 · Market Split ms_13_200_003 · Market Split ms_14_050_000 · Market Split ms_14_050_001 · Market Split ms_14_050_002 · Market Split ms_14_050_003 · Market Split ms_14_100_000 · Market Split ms_14_100_001 · Market Split ms_14_100_002 · Market Split ms_14_100_003 · Market Split ms_14_200_000 · Market Split ms_14_200_001 · Market Split ms_14_200_002 · Market Split ms_14_200_003 · Market Split ms_15_050_000 · Market Split ms_15_050_001 · Market Split ms_15_050_002 · Market Split ms_15_050_003 · Market Split ms_15_100_000 · Market Split ms_15_100_001 · Market Split ms_15_100_002 · Market Split ms_15_100_003 · Market Split ms_15_200_000 · Market Split ms_15_200_001 · Market Split ms_15_200_002 · Market Split ms_15_200_003 · Market Split labs002 · LABS labs003 · LABS labs004 · LABS labs005 · LABS labs006 · LABS labs007 · LABS labs008 · LABS labs009 · LABS labs010 · LABS labs011 · LABS labs012 · LABS labs013 · LABS labs014 · LABS labs015 · LABS labs016 · LABS labs017 · LABS labs018 · LABS labs019 · LABS labs020 · LABS labs021 · LABS labs022 · LABS labs023 · LABS labs024 · LABS labs025 · LABS labs026 · LABS labs027 · LABS labs028 · LABS labs029 · LABS labs030 · LABS labs031 · LABS labs032 · LABS labs033 · LABS labs034 · LABS labs035 · LABS labs036 · LABS labs037 · LABS labs038 · LABS labs039 · LABS labs040 · LABS labs041 · LABS labs042 · LABS labs043 · LABS labs044 · LABS labs045 · LABS labs046 · LABS labs047 · LABS labs048 · LABS labs049 · LABS labs050 · LABS labs051 · LABS labs052 · LABS labs053 · LABS labs054 · LABS labs055 · LABS labs056 · LABS labs057 · LABS labs058 · LABS labs059 · LABS labs060 · LABS labs061 · LABS labs062 · LABS labs063 · LABS labs064 · LABS labs065 · LABS labs066 · LABS labs067 · LABS labs068 · LABS labs069 · LABS labs070 · LABS labs071 · LABS labs072 · LABS labs073 · LABS labs074 · LABS labs075 · LABS labs076 · LABS labs077 · LABS labs078 · LABS labs079 · LABS labs080 · LABS labs081 · LABS labs082 · LABS labs083 · LABS labs084 · LABS labs085 · LABS labs086 · LABS labs087 · LABS labs088 · LABS labs089 · LABS labs090 · LABS labs091 · LABS labs092 · LABS labs093 · LABS labs094 · LABS labs095 · LABS labs096 · LABS labs097 · LABS labs098 · LABS labs099 · LABS labs100 · LABS B3_3_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_3_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B3_9_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_16_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B4_4_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_25_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B5_5_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_36_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_1 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_10 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_2 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_3 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_4 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_5 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_6 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_7 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_8 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition B6_6_9 · Min. Birkhoff Decomposition stp_s003_l1_t2_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l1_t2_h5_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l1_t2_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l1_t3_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s004_l1_t2_h4_rs37235 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s004_l1_t3_h3_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l2_t2_h5_rs37235 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l2_t2_h4_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s004_l1_t3_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s003_l1_t3_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l2_t3_h2_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l2_t4_h3_rs37235 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l2_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l5_t4_h3_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l2_t3_h3_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l3_t4_h3_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l3_t4_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l4_t4_h3_rs37235 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l3_t3_h2_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l4_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l3_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l3_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l2_t4_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l5_t3_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l2_t3_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l2_t3_h3_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l2_t5_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l4_t3_h3_rs37235 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s020_l5_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l3_t3_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l3_t3_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l2_t4_h3_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l2_t3_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l2_t3_h2_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l3_t5_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l4_t3_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l2_t4_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t3_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l4_t4_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l5_t3_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t3_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l3_t4_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t6_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l4_t4_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l3_t3_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s030_l5_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t4_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t4_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l3_t4_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l4_t3_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l2_t5_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l4_t4_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l4_t4_h0_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t4_h2_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l5_t3_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l4_t4_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t4_h2_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t3_h3_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l5_t4_h1_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l4_t4_h2_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t4_h0_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l5_t4_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l4_t5_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l3_t5_h1_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l4_t4_h2_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s040_l5_t5_h0_rs24098 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l5_t4_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l5_t4_h2_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l4_t5_h0_rs97531 · Steiner Tree Packing stp_s050_l4_t4_h0_rs123 · Steiner Tree Packing Addition_000_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_003_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_005_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_007_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_015_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_016_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_018_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_020_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_024_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_025_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_027_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_028_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_029_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_030_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_032_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_034_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_035_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_043_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_044_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_046_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_047_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_048_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_050_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_052_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_064_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_066_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_067_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_068_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_069_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_070_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_082_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_083_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_085_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_090_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_100_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_104_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_105_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_107_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_109_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_110_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_111_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_128_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_129_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_130_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_132_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_133_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_152_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_005_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_010_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Late_005_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Middle_002_Tiny · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_000_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_003_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_005_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_007_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_015_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_016_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_018_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_020_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_024_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_025_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_027_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_028_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_029_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_030_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_032_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_034_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_035_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_043_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_044_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_046_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_047_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_048_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_050_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_052_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_064_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_066_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_067_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_068_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_069_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_070_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_082_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_083_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_085_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_090_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_100_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_104_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_105_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_107_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_109_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_110_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_111_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_128_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_129_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_130_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_132_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_133_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_152_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_005_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_010_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Late_005_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Middle_002_Small · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_000_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_003_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_005_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_007_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_015_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_016_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_018_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_020_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_024_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_025_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_027_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_028_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_029_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_030_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_032_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_034_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_035_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_043_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_044_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_046_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_047_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_048_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_050_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_052_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_064_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_066_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_067_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_068_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_069_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_070_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_082_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_083_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_085_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_090_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_100_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_104_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_105_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_107_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_109_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_110_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_111_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_128_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_129_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_130_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_132_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_133_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_152_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_005_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_010_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Late_005_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Middle_002_Medium · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_003_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_007_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_015_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_020_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_025_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_032_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_035_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_043_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_044_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_046_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_048_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_052_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_069_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_070_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_085_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_104_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_105_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_107_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_109_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_110_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_128_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_129_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_132_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_152_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_02 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_01 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_02 · Sports Tournament Scheduling Middle_002_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_01 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_02 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_03 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_01 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_03 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_03 · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_005_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_024_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_027_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_030_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_034_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_047_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_064_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_066_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_067_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_068_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_082_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_083_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_100_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_133_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_005_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_04 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_05 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_07 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_04 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_06 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_07 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_08 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_04 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_06 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_07 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_08 · Sports Tournament Scheduling Late_005_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_06 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_08 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_09 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_05 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_09 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_05 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_09 · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_000_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_016_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_018_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_028_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_029_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_050_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_090_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_111_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Addition_130_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling Early_010_NoSoft · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_10 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_11 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_12 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_13 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_10 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_12 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_10 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_13 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_15 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_14 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Early_15 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_11 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_13 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_14 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Late_15 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_11 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_12 · Sports Tournament Scheduling ITC2021_Middle_14 · Sports Tournament Scheduling a010_t10_orig_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization farm · Maximum Independent Set mammalia-kangaroo-interactions · Maximum Independent Set johnson8-2-4 · Maximum Independent Set ibm32 · Maximum Independent Set karate · Maximum Independent Set football · Maximum Independent Set chesapeake · Maximum Independent Set MANN-a9 · Maximum Independent Set aves-sparrow-social · Maximum Independent Set insecta-ant-colony1-day38 · Maximum Independent Set hamming6-2 · Maximum Independent Set hamming6-4 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1dc_64 · Maximum Independent Set johnson8-4-4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst03 · Maximum Independent Set johnson16-2-4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst01 · Maximum Independent Set C125-9 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1dc_128 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1zc_128 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_2dc_128 · Maximum Independent Set insecta-ant-colony3-day09 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst04 · Maximum Independent Set keller4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst02 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-1 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-2 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-3 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-4 · Maximum Independent Set c-fat200-1 · Maximum Independent Set gen200_p0-9_44 · Maximum Independent Set brock400-1 · Maximum Independent Set C500-9 · Maximum Independent Set R_500_005_1 · Maximum Independent Set brock800-1 · Maximum Independent Set frb45-21-3 · Maximum Independent Set R_1000_005_1 · Maximum Independent Set hamming10-4 · Maximum Independent Set frb50-23-3 · Maximum Independent Set frb53-24-1 · Maximum Independent Set socfb-haverford76 · Maximum Independent Set p_hat1500-1 · Maximum Independent Set p_hat1500-3 · Maximum Independent Set frb59-26-2 · Maximum Independent Set sorrell4 · Maximum Independent Set sorrell7 · Maximum Independent Set socfb-trinity100 · Maximum Independent Set keller6 · Maximum Independent Set C4000-5 · Maximum Independent Set frb100-40 · Maximum Independent Set network05 · Network Design network06 · Network Design network07 · Network Design network08 · Network Design network09 · Network Design network10 · Network Design network11 · Network Design network12 · Network Design network13 · Network Design network14 · Network Design network15 · Network Design network16 · Network Design network17 · Network Design network18 · Network Design network19 · Network Design network20 · Network Design network21 · Network Design network22 · Network Design network23 · Network Design network24 · Network Design XSH-n20-k4-01 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-02 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-03 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-04 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-05 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-06 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-07 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-08 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-09 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-10 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-11 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-12 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-13 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-14 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-15 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-16 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-17 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-18 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-19 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-20 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-21 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-22 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-23 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-24 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-25 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-26 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-27 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-28 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-29 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-30 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-31 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-32 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-33 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-34 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-35 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-36 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-37 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-38 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-39 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-40 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-41 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-42 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-43 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-44 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-45 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-46 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-47 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-48 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-49 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-50 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-51 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-52 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-53 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-54 · Vehicle Routing XSH-n20-k4-55 · Vehicle Routing topology_15_3 · Topology Design topology_15_4 · Topology Design topology_20_3 · Topology Design topology_20_4 · Topology Design topology_20_5 · Topology Design topology_25_3 · Topology Design topology_25_4 · Topology Design topology_25_5 · Topology Design topology_25_6 · Topology Design topology_30_4 · Topology Design topology_30_5 · Topology Design topology_30_6 · Topology Design topology_35_5 · Topology Design topology_35_6 · Topology Design topology_40_6 · Topology Design topology_50_4 · Topology Design
01
Market Split
02
LABS
03
Min. Birkhoff Decomposition
04
Steiner Tree Packing
05
Sports Tournament Scheduling
06
Portfolio Optimization
07
Maximum Independent Set
08
Network Design
09
Vehicle Routing
10
Topology Design
Classical
optimal
best-known
open
Quantum
optimal
best-known
open
Mixed Integer Programming formulations — variables vs. density, with classical / quantum insets (optimal · best-known · open)
Scatter plot of QUBO benchmark instances by number of variables (log scale, horizontal) and constraint density (log scale, vertical), coloured by problem class. 241 of 433 instances plotted are solved to optimality. 10 100 1,000 10,000 0.01 0.1 1 Number of variables (log) Density (log) ms_03_050_002 · Market Split ms_03_050_005 · Market Split ms_03_050_007 · Market Split ms_03_050_009 · Market Split ms_03_100_001 · Market Split ms_03_100_012 · Market Split ms_03_100_019 · Market Split ms_03_100_022 · Market Split ms_03_200_050 · Market Split ms_03_200_068 · Market Split ms_03_200_161 · Market Split ms_03_200_177 · Market Split ms_04_050_001 · Market Split ms_04_050_003 · Market Split ms_04_050_004 · Market Split ms_04_050_005 · Market Split ms_04_100_003 · Market Split ms_04_100_009 · Market Split ms_04_100_013 · Market Split ms_04_100_015 · Market Split ms_04_200_030 · Market Split ms_04_200_150 · Market Split ms_04_200_174 · Market Split ms_04_200_176 · Market Split ms_05_050_001 · Market Split ms_05_050_002 · Market Split ms_05_050_003 · Market Split ms_05_050_004 · Market Split ms_05_100_003 · Market Split ms_05_100_006 · Market Split ms_05_100_013 · Market Split ms_05_100_015 · Market Split ms_05_200_070 · Market Split ms_05_200_095 · Market Split ms_05_200_180 · Market Split ms_05_200_199 · Market Split ms_06_050_001 · Market Split ms_06_050_002 · Market Split ms_06_050_003 · Market Split ms_06_050_004 · Market Split ms_06_100_002 · Market Split ms_06_100_003 · Market Split ms_06_100_005 · Market Split ms_06_100_010 · Market Split ms_06_200_077 · Market Split ms_06_200_104 · Market Split ms_06_200_240 · Market Split ms_06_200_289 · Market Split ms_07_050_001 · Market Split ms_07_050_002 · Market Split ms_07_050_003 · Market Split ms_07_050_004 · Market Split ms_07_100_002 · Market Split ms_07_100_003 · Market Split ms_07_100_005 · Market Split ms_07_100_006 · Market Split ms_07_200_248 · Market Split ms_07_200_370 · Market Split ms_07_200_398 · Market Split ms_07_200_500 · Market Split ms_08_050_000 · Market Split ms_08_050_001 · Market Split ms_08_050_002 · Market Split ms_08_050_003 · Market Split ms_08_100_000 · Market Split ms_08_100_001 · Market Split ms_08_100_002 · Market Split ms_08_100_003 · Market Split ms_08_200_000 · Market Split ms_08_200_001 · Market Split ms_08_200_002 · Market Split ms_08_200_003 · Market Split ms_09_050_000 · Market Split ms_09_050_001 · Market Split ms_09_050_002 · Market Split ms_09_050_003 · Market Split ms_09_100_000 · Market Split ms_09_100_001 · Market Split ms_09_100_002 · Market Split ms_09_100_003 · Market Split ms_09_200_000 · Market Split ms_09_200_001 · Market Split ms_09_200_002 · Market Split ms_09_200_003 · Market Split ms_10_050_000 · Market Split ms_10_050_001 · Market Split ms_10_050_002 · Market Split ms_10_050_003 · Market Split ms_10_100_000 · Market Split ms_10_100_001 · Market Split ms_10_100_002 · Market Split ms_10_100_003 · Market Split ms_10_200_000 · Market Split ms_10_200_001 · Market Split ms_10_200_002 · Market Split ms_10_200_003 · Market Split ms_11_050_000 · Market Split ms_11_050_001 · Market Split ms_11_050_002 · Market Split ms_11_050_003 · Market Split ms_11_100_000 · Market Split ms_11_100_001 · Market Split ms_11_100_002 · Market Split ms_11_100_003 · Market Split ms_11_200_000 · Market Split ms_11_200_001 · Market Split ms_11_200_002 · Market Split ms_11_200_003 · Market Split ms_12_050_000 · Market Split ms_12_050_001 · Market Split ms_12_050_002 · Market Split ms_12_050_003 · Market Split ms_12_100_000 · Market Split ms_12_100_001 · Market Split ms_12_100_002 · Market Split ms_12_100_003 · Market Split ms_12_200_000 · Market Split ms_12_200_001 · Market Split ms_12_200_002 · Market Split ms_12_200_003 · Market Split ms_13_050_000 · Market Split ms_13_050_001 · Market Split ms_13_050_002 · Market Split ms_13_050_003 · Market Split ms_13_100_000 · Market Split ms_13_100_001 · Market Split ms_13_100_002 · Market Split ms_13_100_003 · Market Split ms_13_200_000 · Market Split ms_13_200_001 · Market Split ms_13_200_002 · Market Split ms_13_200_003 · Market Split ms_14_050_000 · Market Split ms_14_050_001 · Market Split ms_14_050_002 · Market Split ms_14_050_003 · Market Split ms_14_100_000 · Market Split ms_14_100_001 · Market Split ms_14_100_002 · Market Split ms_14_100_003 · Market Split ms_14_200_000 · Market Split ms_14_200_001 · Market Split ms_14_200_002 · Market Split ms_14_200_003 · Market Split ms_15_050_000 · Market Split ms_15_050_001 · Market Split ms_15_050_002 · Market Split ms_15_050_003 · Market Split ms_15_100_000 · Market Split ms_15_100_001 · Market Split ms_15_100_002 · Market Split ms_15_100_003 · Market Split ms_15_200_000 · Market Split ms_15_200_001 · Market Split ms_15_200_002 · Market Split ms_15_200_003 · Market Split labs002 · LABS labs003 · LABS labs004 · LABS labs005 · LABS labs006 · LABS labs007 · LABS labs008 · LABS labs009 · LABS labs010 · LABS labs011 · LABS labs012 · LABS labs013 · LABS labs014 · LABS labs015 · LABS labs016 · LABS labs017 · LABS labs018 · LABS labs019 · LABS labs020 · LABS labs021 · LABS labs022 · LABS labs023 · LABS labs024 · LABS labs025 · LABS labs026 · LABS labs027 · LABS labs028 · LABS labs029 · LABS labs030 · LABS labs031 · LABS labs032 · LABS labs033 · LABS labs034 · LABS labs035 · LABS labs036 · LABS labs037 · LABS labs038 · LABS labs039 · LABS labs040 · LABS labs041 · LABS labs042 · LABS labs043 · LABS labs044 · LABS labs045 · LABS labs046 · LABS labs047 · LABS labs048 · LABS labs049 · LABS labs050 · LABS labs051 · LABS labs052 · LABS labs053 · LABS labs054 · LABS labs055 · LABS labs056 · LABS labs057 · LABS labs058 · LABS labs059 · LABS labs060 · LABS labs061 · LABS labs062 · LABS labs063 · LABS labs064 · LABS labs065 · LABS labs066 · LABS labs067 · LABS labs068 · LABS labs069 · LABS labs070 · LABS labs071 · LABS labs072 · LABS labs073 · LABS labs074 · LABS labs075 · LABS labs076 · LABS labs077 · LABS labs078 · LABS labs079 · LABS labs080 · LABS labs081 · LABS labs082 · LABS labs083 · LABS labs084 · LABS labs085 · LABS labs086 · LABS labs087 · LABS labs088 · LABS labs089 · LABS labs090 · LABS labs091 · LABS labs092 · LABS labs093 · LABS labs094 · LABS labs095 · LABS labs096 · LABS labs097 · LABS labs098 · LABS labs099 · LABS labs100 · LABS a010_t10_orig_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_orig_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s00_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s01_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t10_s02_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_orig_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s00_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s01_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a010_t15_s02_b004_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_orig_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s00_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s01_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t10_s02_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_orig_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s00_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s01_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l0 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-02 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-03 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-05 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l1e-06 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l5e-04 · Portfolio Optimization a050_t15_s02_b020_l5e-05 · Portfolio Optimization farm · Maximum Independent Set mammalia-kangaroo-interactions · Maximum Independent Set johnson8-2-4 · Maximum Independent Set ibm32 · Maximum Independent Set karate · Maximum Independent Set football · Maximum Independent Set chesapeake · Maximum Independent Set MANN-a9 · Maximum Independent Set aves-sparrow-social · Maximum Independent Set insecta-ant-colony1-day38 · Maximum Independent Set hamming6-2 · Maximum Independent Set hamming6-4 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1dc_64 · Maximum Independent Set johnson8-4-4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst03 · Maximum Independent Set johnson16-2-4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst01 · Maximum Independent Set C125-9 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1dc_128 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_1zc_128 · Maximum Independent Set sloane_2dc_128 · Maximum Independent Set insecta-ant-colony3-day09 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst04 · Maximum Independent Set keller4 · Maximum Independent Set es60fst02 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-1 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-2 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-3 · Maximum Independent Set brock200-4 · Maximum Independent Set c-fat200-1 · Maximum Independent Set gen200_p0-9_44 · Maximum Independent Set brock400-1 · Maximum Independent Set C500-9 · Maximum Independent Set R_500_005_1 · Maximum Independent Set brock800-1 · Maximum Independent Set frb45-21-3 · Maximum Independent Set R_1000_005_1 · Maximum Independent Set hamming10-4 · Maximum Independent Set frb50-23-3 · Maximum Independent Set frb53-24-1 · Maximum Independent Set socfb-haverford76 · Maximum Independent Set p_hat1500-1 · Maximum Independent Set p_hat1500-3 · Maximum Independent Set frb59-26-2 · Maximum Independent Set sorrell4 · Maximum Independent Set sorrell7 · Maximum Independent Set socfb-trinity100 · Maximum Independent Set keller6 · Maximum Independent Set C4000-5 · Maximum Independent Set frb100-40 · Maximum Independent Set
01
Market Split
02
LABS
06
Portfolio Optimization
07
Maximum Independent Set
Classical
optimal
best-known
open
Quantum
optimal
best-known
open
QUBO formulations — variables vs. density, with classical / quantum insets (optimal · best-known · open)
Classical
Solved (optimal)
Matches best-known
Open
Quantum
Solved (optimal)
Matches best-known
Open
01
Market Split
Multi-dimensional Subset Sum
These instances stress multi-constraint subset-sum structure, where feasibility is easy to state but difficult to certify at useful sizes.
02
LABS
Low Autocorrelation Binary Sequences
LABS is a canonical spin benchmark with direct links to communications, radar, and cryptography, and it becomes harder as sequence length grows.
03
Min. Birkhoff Decomposition
Doubly Stochastic Matrix Decomposition
Minimum Birkhoff decomposition links assignment structure, sparse representation, and quantum physics applications through a hard cardinality objective.
04
Steiner Tree Packing
VLSI Design / Wire Routing
Steiner tree packing models wire-routing pressure in VLSI-style grids, where many connection demands must coexist without conflicts.
05
Sports Tournament Scheduling
Constraint Satisfaction / Scheduling
Sports timetabling captures realistic constraint interactions from round-robin tournaments, with instances selected for diversity and difficulty.
06
Portfolio Optimization
Multi-period with Transaction Costs & Short Selling
Portfolio instances add transaction costs, short selling, borrowing costs, and time coupling to a familiar financial optimization model.
07
Maximum Independent Set
Unweighted MIS on Hard Graphs
Maximum independent set is a fundamental graph problem with compact QUBO structure and hard instances from social, biological, and benchmark graphs.
08
Network Design
Telecommunications Network Planning
Network design represents traffic-routing and degree-constrained infrastructure planning, with objective values tied to congestion.
09
Vehicle Routing
VRP with Time Windows + Capacity
Vehicle routing combines route selection, capacity, and time-window pressure, reflecting core logistics and mobility applications.
10
Topology Design
Graph Golf / Node-Degree-Diameter Problem
Topology design asks for low-diameter graphs under degree limits, a concise model for communication latency and network architecture.