← Back to Problems
02 / labs

LABS

Low Autocorrelation Binary Sequences
Binary QUBO signal-processing dense NP-hard
Instances 99
Optimally solved 65 / 99
Variable range 2–100
Objective minimize

Overview

The Low Autocorrelation Binary Sequences (LABS) problem seeks binary sequences with minimal autocorrelation properties. This problem has applications in communications, radar systems, and cryptography, where low autocorrelation is desirable to minimize signal interference.

Problem Description

Given a sequence $\mathcal{S} = \{s_1, \ldots, s_n\}$ of spins $s_i \in \{-1,1\}$ for $i \in [n]$, we define:

Autocorrelations: $$ C_k(\mathcal{S}) \coloneqq \sum_{i = 1}^{n-k} s_i s_{i+k} $$

Energy (Objective Function): $$ E(\mathcal{S}) \coloneqq \sum_{k=1}^{n-1} C_k^2(\mathcal{S}) $$

Goal: Find the binary sequence $\mathcal{S}$ of length $n$ that minimizes $E(\mathcal{S})$.

±1 sequence (length 11)autocorrelation Cₖ (max |Cₖ| = 1)

Performance

Runtime to reach best-known objective

Sorted instances vs total runtime. A point (x, y) means x instances were solved within y seconds. Solid line + filled circle = proven exact; dashed line + open diamond = heuristic. Lower-right is better.

Classical (69 · heuristic) Quantum simulator (1 · heuristic) Quantum hardware (5 · heuristic)
Cactus plot: cumulative number of instances solved (horizontal) versus total runtime in seconds on a log scale (vertical), one line per method group; lower-right is better.1.0e-400.010.11101001,0000122436486069instances solved →runtime (s, log)Classical · heuristic · labs002 · 9.3e-5 sClassical · heuristic · labs004 · 1.1e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs005 · 1.2e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs008 · 1.3e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs009 · 1.4e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs006 · 1.4e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs007 · 1.5e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs012 · 1.5e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs013 · 1.6e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs011 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs014 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs010 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs016 · 1.8e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs015 · 1.8e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs017 · 2.0e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs019 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs020 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs018 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs021 · 2.5e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs022 · 2.6e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs003 · 8.2e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs023 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs024 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs026 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs025 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs028 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs029 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs030 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs032 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs035 · 0.04 sClassical · heuristic · labs046 · 0.05 sClassical · heuristic · labs027 · 0.31 sClassical · heuristic · labs031 · 0.32 sClassical · heuristic · labs033 · 0.37 sClassical · heuristic · labs037 · 0.41 sClassical · heuristic · labs034 · 0.41 sClassical · heuristic · labs038 · 0.45 sClassical · heuristic · labs036 · 4.19 sClassical · heuristic · labs040 · 4.58 sClassical · heuristic · labs042 · 23.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs061 · 35.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs049 · 37 sClassical · heuristic · labs044 · 40.5 sClassical · heuristic · labs039 · 42.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs043 · 48.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs045 · 96 sClassical · heuristic · labs047 · 97.8 sClassical · heuristic · labs048 · 99.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs050 · 104.6 sClassical · heuristic · labs055 · 168.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs041 · 278.6 sClassical · heuristic · labs051 · 323.5 sClassical · heuristic · labs052 · 339.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs053 · 391.8 sClassical · heuristic · labs056 · 396.9 sClassical · heuristic · labs054 · 408.4 sClassical · heuristic · labs057 · 412.5 sClassical · heuristic · labs058 · 436.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs062 · 456.9 sClassical · heuristic · labs059 · 458.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs060 · 477.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs063 · 480.1 sClassical · heuristic · labs064 · 491.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs065 · 495.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs068 · 511.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs069 · 535.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs070 · 577 sClassical · heuristic · labs066 · 651.1 sClassical · heuristic · labs072 · 707.3 sQuantum simulator · heuristic · labs003 · 0.11 sQuantum hardware · heuristic · labs020 · 61.2 sQuantum hardware · heuristic · labs006 · 280.3 sQuantum hardware · heuristic · labs008 · 648.8 sQuantum hardware · heuristic · labs010 · 1,187 sQuantum hardware · heuristic · labs012 · 2,523 s

Time-to-solution (TTS) to reach best-known objective

Same as the runtime cactus but uses the reported Time-to-Solution rather than total runtime. Solid = exact, dashed = heuristic.

Classical (69 · 20 exact, 49 heuristic)
Cactus plot: cumulative number of instances solved (horizontal) versus time-to-solution in seconds on a log scale (vertical), one line per method group; lower-right is better.00.010.11101001,0000122436486069instances solved →time-to-solution (s, log)Classical · exact · labs002 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs003 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs004 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs005 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs006 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs007 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs008 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs009 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs010 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs011 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs012 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs013 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs014 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs015 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs016 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs017 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs018 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs019 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs020 · 0 sClassical · exact · labs022 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs021 · 2.5e-4 sClassical · heuristic · labs023 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs024 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs026 · 0 sClassical · heuristic · labs025 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs028 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs029 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs030 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs032 · 0.03 sClassical · heuristic · labs035 · 0.04 sClassical · heuristic · labs046 · 0.05 sClassical · heuristic · labs027 · 0.31 sClassical · heuristic · labs031 · 0.32 sClassical · heuristic · labs033 · 0.37 sClassical · heuristic · labs037 · 0.41 sClassical · heuristic · labs034 · 0.41 sClassical · heuristic · labs038 · 0.45 sClassical · heuristic · labs036 · 1.13 sClassical · heuristic · labs039 · 2.39 sClassical · heuristic · labs044 · 2.54 sClassical · heuristic · labs040 · 2.57 sClassical · heuristic · labs042 · 2.61 sClassical · heuristic · labs049 · 2.79 sClassical · heuristic · labs061 · 3.72 sClassical · heuristic · labs045 · 22.8 sClassical · heuristic · labs047 · 47.5 sClassical · heuristic · labs043 · 48.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs041 · 70 sClassical · heuristic · labs048 · 99.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs050 · 104.6 sClassical · heuristic · labs055 · 168.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs052 · 258 sClassical · heuristic · labs054 · 287 sClassical · heuristic · labs053 · 291 sClassical · heuristic · labs051 · 300.9 sClassical · heuristic · labs057 · 366.6 sClassical · heuristic · labs056 · 387.4 sClassical · heuristic · labs058 · 401.8 sClassical · heuristic · labs062 · 402.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs069 · 419.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs059 · 419.8 sClassical · heuristic · labs060 · 427.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs068 · 445.2 sClassical · heuristic · labs064 · 445.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs065 · 449.7 sClassical · heuristic · labs063 · 451.6 sClassical · heuristic · labs066 · 493.3 sClassical · heuristic · labs072 · 554.5 sClassical · heuristic · labs070 · 554.7 s

Solution quality (performance profile)

Share of instances each group brings within a given optimality gap of the best-known objective. Higher is better; the value at “best” is the share solved exactly.

Classical (99) Quantum simulator (1) Quantum hardware (5)
Performance profile: share of instances (vertical) reached within a given optimality gap of the best-known objective (horizontal), one line per method group; higher is better.0%25%50%75%100%best+1.5%+5.2%+14%+38%optimality gap from best-known →instances solved (%)Classical · within best · 70% · labs002, labs003, labs004, labs005, labs006, labs007, labs008, labs009, labs010, labs011, labs012, labs013, labs014, labs015, labs016, labs017, labs018, labs019, labs020, labs021, labs022, labs023, labs024, labs025, labs026, labs027, labs028, labs029, labs030, labs031, labs032, labs033, labs034, labs035, labs036, labs037, labs038, labs039, labs040, labs041, labs042, labs043, labs044, labs045, labs046, labs047, labs048, labs049, labs050, labs051, labs052, labs053, labs054, labs055, labs056, labs057, labs058, labs059, labs060, labs061, labs062, labs063, labs064, labs065, labs066, labs068, labs069, labs070, labs072Classical · within +2.3% · 71% · labs074Classical · within +2.6% · 72% · labs073Classical · within +3.6% · 73% · labs075Classical · within +7.3% · 74% · labs086Classical · within +8.4% · 75% · labs084Classical · within +8.4% · 76% · labs076Classical · within +9.1% · 77% · labs080Classical · within +9.7% · 78% · labs081Classical · within +10% · 79% · labs077Classical · within +10% · 80% · labs098Classical · within +13% · 81% · labs067Classical · within +14% · 82% · labs087Classical · within +15% · 83% · labs100Classical · within +16% · 84% · labs083Classical · within +16% · 85% · labs092Classical · within +16% · 86% · labs085Classical · within +18% · 87% · labs088Classical · within +18% · 88% · labs078Classical · within +19% · 89% · labs097Classical · within +19% · 90% · labs071Classical · within +19% · 91% · labs089Classical · within +20% · 92% · labs079Classical · within +21% · 93% · labs096Classical · within +21% · 94% · labs082Classical · within +23% · 95% · labs091Classical · within +25% · 96% · labs090Classical · within +26% · 97% · labs099Classical · within +27% · 98% · labs093Classical · within +27% · 99% · labs094Classical · within +38% · 100% · labs095Quantum simulator · within best · 1% · labs003Quantum hardware · within best · 5% · labs006, labs008, labs010, labs012, labs020

Runtime scaling with instance size

Fastest feasible runtime (log scale) per instance versus Length N — shows how each group scales.

Classical (99) Quantum simulator (1) Quantum hardware (5)
Scaling plot: fastest feasible runtime in seconds on a log scale (vertical) versus Length N (horizontal), one series per method group.1.0e-400.010.11101001,00020406080100Length N →runtime (s, log)Classical · labs002 · Length N 2 · 9.3e-5 sClassical · labs003 · Length N 3 · 8.2e-4 sClassical · labs004 · Length N 4 · 1.1e-4 sClassical · labs005 · Length N 5 · 1.2e-4 sClassical · labs006 · Length N 6 · 1.4e-4 sClassical · labs007 · Length N 7 · 1.5e-4 sClassical · labs008 · Length N 8 · 1.3e-4 sClassical · labs009 · Length N 9 · 1.4e-4 sClassical · labs010 · Length N 10 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · labs011 · Length N 11 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · labs012 · Length N 12 · 1.5e-4 sClassical · labs013 · Length N 13 · 1.6e-4 sClassical · labs014 · Length N 14 · 1.7e-4 sClassical · labs015 · Length N 15 · 1.8e-4 sClassical · labs016 · Length N 16 · 1.8e-4 sClassical · labs017 · Length N 17 · 2.0e-4 sClassical · labs018 · Length N 18 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · labs019 · Length N 19 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · labs020 · Length N 20 · 2.2e-4 sClassical · labs021 · Length N 21 · 2.5e-4 sClassical · labs022 · Length N 22 · 2.6e-4 sClassical · labs023 · Length N 23 · 0 sClassical · labs024 · Length N 24 · 0 sClassical · labs025 · Length N 25 · 0.03 sClassical · labs026 · Length N 26 · 0 sClassical · labs027 · Length N 27 · 0.31 sClassical · labs028 · Length N 28 · 0.03 sClassical · labs029 · Length N 29 · 0.03 sClassical · labs030 · Length N 30 · 0.03 sClassical · labs031 · Length N 31 · 0.32 sClassical · labs032 · Length N 32 · 0.03 sClassical · labs033 · Length N 33 · 0.37 sClassical · labs034 · Length N 34 · 0.41 sClassical · labs035 · Length N 35 · 0.04 sClassical · labs036 · Length N 36 · 4.19 sClassical · labs037 · Length N 37 · 0.41 sClassical · labs038 · Length N 38 · 0.45 sClassical · labs039 · Length N 39 · 42.2 sClassical · labs040 · Length N 40 · 4.58 sClassical · labs041 · Length N 41 · 24.4 sClassical · labs042 · Length N 42 · 23.3 sClassical · labs043 · Length N 43 · 30.8 sClassical · labs044 · Length N 44 · 30.5 sClassical · labs045 · Length N 45 · 29.7 sClassical · labs046 · Length N 46 · 0.05 sClassical · labs047 · Length N 47 · 25.4 sClassical · labs048 · Length N 48 · 25.6 sClassical · labs049 · Length N 49 · 27 sClassical · labs050 · Length N 50 · 30.3 sClassical · labs051 · Length N 51 · 31.5 sClassical · labs052 · Length N 52 · 23.4 sClassical · labs053 · Length N 53 · 23.7 sClassical · labs054 · Length N 54 · 24.1 sClassical · labs055 · Length N 55 · 26.3 sClassical · labs056 · Length N 56 · 30.9 sClassical · labs057 · Length N 57 · 27.1 sClassical · labs058 · Length N 58 · 30.3 sClassical · labs059 · Length N 59 · 26.1 sClassical · labs060 · Length N 60 · 28.6 sClassical · labs061 · Length N 61 · 25.7 sClassical · labs062 · Length N 62 · 32.3 sClassical · labs063 · Length N 63 · 27.9 sClassical · labs064 · Length N 64 · 39.3 sClassical · labs065 · Length N 65 · 33 sClassical · labs066 · Length N 66 · 32.2 sClassical · labs067 · Length N 67 · 33 sClassical · labs068 · Length N 68 · 31 sClassical · labs069 · Length N 69 · 32.5 sClassical · labs070 · Length N 70 · 31.8 sClassical · labs071 · Length N 71 · 45.4 sClassical · labs072 · Length N 72 · 50.3 sClassical · labs073 · Length N 73 · 34.9 sClassical · labs074 · Length N 74 · 58.3 sClassical · labs075 · Length N 75 · 32.9 sClassical · labs076 · Length N 76 · 49.5 sClassical · labs077 · Length N 77 · 55.5 sClassical · labs078 · Length N 78 · 42 sClassical · labs079 · Length N 79 · 33.1 sClassical · labs080 · Length N 80 · 30.9 sClassical · labs081 · Length N 81 · 51.4 sClassical · labs082 · Length N 82 · 44.4 sClassical · labs083 · Length N 83 · 42.7 sClassical · labs084 · Length N 84 · 36.4 sClassical · labs085 · Length N 85 · 37.7 sClassical · labs086 · Length N 86 · 39 sClassical · labs087 · Length N 87 · 50.1 sClassical · labs088 · Length N 88 · 101.6 sClassical · labs089 · Length N 89 · 47.1 sClassical · labs090 · Length N 90 · 67.5 sClassical · labs091 · Length N 91 · 53 sClassical · labs092 · Length N 92 · 44.8 sClassical · labs093 · Length N 93 · 38.6 sClassical · labs094 · Length N 94 · 81.5 sClassical · labs095 · Length N 95 · 52.1 sClassical · labs096 · Length N 96 · 35.7 sClassical · labs097 · Length N 97 · 42.6 sClassical · labs098 · Length N 98 · 55.3 sClassical · labs099 · Length N 99 · 153.3 sClassical · labs100 · Length N 100 · 56.4 sQuantum simulator · labs003 · Length N 3 · 0.11 sQuantum hardware · labs006 · Length N 6 · 280.3 sQuantum hardware · labs008 · Length N 8 · 648.8 sQuantum hardware · labs010 · Length N 10 · 1,187 sQuantum hardware · labs012 · Length N 12 · 2,523 sQuantum hardware · labs020 · Length N 20 · 61.2 s

Submissions (9)

Method Submitter Type Date Instances
dSB Tim Bode Classical 2026-08-20 99
Quicopt Tim Bode Classical 2026-08-15 99
PDBOspin Wenbo Liu (UCAS), Akang Wang (SRIBD/CUHKSZ), Dun Ma (UCAS), Hongyi Jiang (CityUHK), Jianghua Wu (SRIBD), Wenguo Yang (UCAS) Classical 2026-07-04 99
PDBO Wenbo Liu (UCAS), Akang Wang (SRIBD/CUHKSZ), Dun Ma (UCAS), Hongyi Jiang (CityUHK), Jianghua Wu (SRIBD), Wenguo Yang (UCAS) Classical 2026-07-04 99
Arvak Daniel Hinderink Quantum sim 2026-03-08 1
QAOA Angelika Widl, Daniel Egger, Juris Ulmanis, Christoph Regner Quantum HW 2025-11-17 8
Abs2 Maximilian Schicker Classical 2025-02-21 99
BF-DCQO Narendra N. Hegade, Alejandro Gomez Cadavid Quantum HW 2025-01-20 1
MIP Maximilian Schicker Classical 20241229 99

Instances (99)

99 of 99
Name Length N Best objective Source Status Download
labs002 2 1 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs003 3 1 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs004 4 2 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs005 5 2 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs006 6 7 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs007 7 3 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs008 8 8 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs009 9 12 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs010 10 13 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs011 11 5 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs012 12 10 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs013 13 6 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs014 14 19 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs015 15 15 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs016 16 24 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs017 17 32 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs018 18 25 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs019 19 29 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs020 20 26 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs021 21 26 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs022 22 39 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs023 23 47 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs024 24 36 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs025 25 36 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs026 26 45 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs027 27 37 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs028 28 50 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs029 29 62 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs030 30 59 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs031 31 67 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs032 32 64 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs033 33 64 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs034 34 65 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs035 35 73 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs036 36 82 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs037 37 86 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs038 38 87 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs039 39 99 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs040 40 108 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs041 41 108 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs042 42 101 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs043 43 109 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs044 44 122 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs045 45 118 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs046 46 131 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs047 47 135 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs048 48 140 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs049 49 136 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs050 50 153 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs051 51 153 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs052 52 166 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs053 53 170 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs054 54 175 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs055 55 171 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs056 56 192 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs057 57 188 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs058 58 197 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs059 59 205 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs060 60 218 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs061 61 226 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs062 62 235 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs063 63 207 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs064 64 208 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs065 65 240 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs066 66 257 Reference solution Optimal ↓ raw
labs067 67 241 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs068 68 250 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs069 69 274 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs070 70 295 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs071 71 275 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs072 72 300 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs073 73 308 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs074 74 341 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs075 75 329 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs076 76 334 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs077 77 358 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs078 78 347 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs079 79 339 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs080 80 352 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs081 81 372 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs082 82 377 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs083 83 377 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs084 84 430 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs085 85 414 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs086 86 439 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs087 87 431 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs088 88 448 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs089 89 432 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs090 90 453 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs091 91 477 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs092 92 498 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs093 93 486 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs094 94 499 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs095 95 479 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs096 96 520 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs097 97 536 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs098 98 545 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs099 99 577 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw
labs100 100 578 Reference solution Best known ↓ raw